Good morning.

The brokerage app you choose to use could make (or lose) you tens of thousands of dollars.

Let us explain.

If you could earn a few hundred bucks every year just for using one brokerage app over another, would you?

We would. That’s because a few hundred bucks is worth so much more in 30 years if you start investing it now. $300 now is $2,434.95 in 30 years (at 7% interest rate). 

But $300 every year for 30 years at 7% interest is $30,621.91.

What about earning 4% or more on uninvested cash, getting access to level II Nasdaq data, leverage…? The list goes on.

The point we’re making is: the seemingly tiny differences between the brokerages you can choose from matter a lot. We want you to make an educated choice (this is not sponsored content, just thought this was a relevant topic for you guys).

So we’re going to look at three different brokerages you could choose to trade with (and some honorable mentions). We’ll walk you through the practical details that actually impact real investors like you.

Note: none of this is sponsored. We just wanted to find out what the incentives are right now on different brokerage apps so we could suggest the best ones wholeheartedly to you.

We’ll show you brokerage accounts that offer:

  • IRA contribution matching of 3% to 3.5%

  • 401(k) transfer matching of up to 3%

  • Forex, crypto, and/or international stock trading

And we will ignore (most of) the brokerages that don’t offer any benefits like those.

Let’s begin.

Credit: Robinhood

The brokerage app that rose to fame (or infamy) during the Covid lock downs of 2020 and led many a retail trader to riches (or disaster): Robinhood.

This is one of the most popular trading apps in the world, and its competitors are constantly having to adapt to the new standards Robinhood sets and what it does for its users.

And boy, does it do a lot for its users.

You can read through the features Robinhood offers below. You only get access to most of the really good features when you pay for a Robinhood Gold membership, which is $5 a month (but is often worth it from a cost-benefit analysis standpoint).

One feature that we want to highlight is the 3% IRA match. That means that each year, if you’re maxing out your IRA contributions ($7,000 per year), Robinhood will contribute $210 to your account. That contribution adds up over time.

And if you already have a 401(k) or an IRA somewhere else and transfer that to Robinhood, the platform will give you a 1% match. That means if you have a $50,000 401(k) but want to turn it into a Robinhood IRA, they will pay you $500 to do that. Just because they want your business.

And even if you just keep cash in your account doing nothing for a while, you still earn 4% APY on it. Which is almost as good as the rates that top banks offer in their savings accounts (and is better than some).

Full Robinhood feature list

  • Robinhood Gold membership ($5/month)

    • 3% IRA match ($210/year if maxed out)

      • (1% for non-gold members)

    • 1% match on current funds if you transfer an existing IRA or 401(k)

    • 4% APY on uninvested cash

    • Your first 30 days are free

    • Level II Nasdaq market data

    • Research from Morningstar’s financial analysts

    • Robinhood Gold card (if you use credit cards)

      • 3% back match on everything, 5% back on travel booked through the RobinHood portal

    • Access to Robinhood Strategies (auto-investing option captained by real professional traders)

  • For non-Gold members:

    • No commission fees on stocks, ETFs, and their options

    • Get a free stock on sign up

    • Trade with margin (if you dare… we don’t recommend it)

      • You get your first $1k of margin interest-free

      • Qualified traders can even trade options within their tax-advantaged retirement account

    • Upcoming: Robinhood Venture Fund I: a way for non-accredited investors to get exposure to private equity

    • IPO access

    • Crypto

      • Lowest crypto fees across the market

      • Stake ETH and SOL

Credit: Webull

If Robinhood had a nemesis, it would be Webull, its more technical but less aesthetically pleasing brother.

It seems like everything that Webull does is in an effort to differentiate itself from Robinhood. It’s kind of like the Apple vs. Android debate, where Webull (Android) beats Robinhood (Apple) on a lot of features…

But Apple has the Apple brand, following, and aesthetics.

You’ll see what we mean in the features list below, but to give a taste:

Robinhood offers 3% IRA matching? Webull does 3.5%.

Robinhood offers 4% APY on sitting cash? Webull does 4.1%.

And yet, we all know that at the end of the day, many traders pick Robinhood because the app just looks and feels way better. You can trade more technically in Webull, but you can trade beautifully in Robinhood.

Overall, if you want to truly optimize for every bit of cash you can get, take Webull. If you don’t mind missing a few percents of a percent, and maybe prefer the human traders in Robinhood’s auto trading to Webull’s robo advisor, take Robinhood for the UX.

Full Webull feature list

  • Webull Premium

    • Webull premium is clearly built out specifically to beat Robinhood Gold in almost every category. I (Blake) just think that Robinhood’s UI is way better than Webull’s for most people. If you really want trading info and technical data galore, choose Webull; if you want a more pleasant experience visually and get your data elsewhere (and don’t mind missing out on the slightly larger interest and IRA contributions Webull has), then maybe go Robinhood. If you want maximum contributions and max data (with minimum pleasantness of UX), go with Webull.

    • Webull has a robo advisor (fee is 0.20%, which is 0.05% lower than Robinhood’s fee. However, Robinhood’s auto trading feature is run by real human trading pros, not robots)

    • 4.1% APY on uninvested cash

    • 3.5% IRA match ($280/year if maxed out)

    • 3% match on current funds if you transfer an existing IRA or 401(k)

    • Free stock(s) on signup 

    • Lower Margin Rates

    • IPO access

Credit: Charles Schwab

And here’s an institutional name you may not have considered before, but that we wanted to include for comparison’s sake.

There’s a lot that Robinhood and Webull do that Charles Schwab can’t do; but the opposite is just as true.

If Robinhood and Webull are all about rewarding the user with benefits, Charles Schwab entices users with more trading options and flexibility than either of the other two.

For example: Charles Schwab has forex, international stocks, bonds, options, and IPOs. Robinhood and Webull have some of those, but not forex or global stocks.

And that’s a big deal to some people, and a small deal to others. It’s all about what you prefer.

We don’t have much more to say about Charles Schwab, just that if you want the widest possible selection of assets to trade (minus crypto), it’s probably the brokerage for you.

  • 0 commissions

  • 0 fees for robo-advisor investing

    • But $5,000 account minimum for robo investing

  • Big plus for some: Charles Schwab has the widest selection of assets out of any option here.

    • U.S. and international stocks

    • ETFs

    • mutual funds

    • bonds

    • options

    • IPOs

    • Futures

    • Forex

  • No IRA matching

  • No crypto trading

  • Only 0.15% APY on uninvested cash

Honorable Mentions:

  • Another modern brokerage app option

  • Main differentiator vs. Robinhood and Webull is that it’s a one-stop shop for banking, lending, credit card and insurance products

    • You also get most features without a membership on SoFi, but the features are the same or worse than Robnhood’s and Webull’s

  • M1’s main differentiating feature is that it’s for set-it-and-forget-it investors

  • After you choose your investment strategy and the allocations for different “pie pieces” in your pie portfolio, you never have to worry about adjusting it again

  • Automatic deposits can be split across dozens of stocks/ETFs in exact percentages

  • It rebalances automatically if things get off in your portfolio

    • The rebalancing is free

  • BUT, it also has margin. You can borrow against your portfolio if you want

  • And a debit card

  • Other than that, it’s pretty limited. None of the options or other features other brokerages offer

  • Round-up investing app for people looking to invest in small increments “passively” over time

  • Another set-it-and-forget-it option

  • Drawback is that you don’t have agency over what your investments go into (beyond choosing the risk level of your portfolio)

    • They put it into pre-built funds for you

    • Which could maybe be good if you struggle with just investing consistently in stable index fund-type stuff—this would be a hedge against gambling on individual stocks and losing it all I guess?

Bottom Line

Overall, you want to get the best value out of your investments. We’re no financial advisors, but it seems obvious to us that if there’s a zero-drawback brokerage that’s offering us hundreds of dollars a year to invest with them, we should take that offer over the brokerages that are giving us less (or nothing) for our business.

And remember, those extra couple hundred dollars (or more) each year can seriously add up over time.

🫡 See You Next Week

That’s all for today’s special edition. We hope you got value from it. Reply and let us know if you did. 

Until next week,

— Brandon & Blake

The information provided in Stocks & Income is for informational and educational purposes only and should not be construed as financial advice, investment advice, or a recommendation to buy or sell any securities. Stocks & Income is not a registered investment advisor, broker-dealer, or licensed financial planner. Always do your own research and consult with a licensed financial advisor before making any investment decisions. We may hold positions in or receive compensation from the companies or products mentioned. Disclosures will be made where applicable.

Reply

or to participate